אין שטחים - יש רק ארץ ישראל
Things I find in my Dad’s study
A giant map of Judea and Samaria with all the accompanying historical and archaeological information.
The map is titled “Historical & Archeological map of Judea and Samaria. (Sometimes called the ‘West Bank’ or the ‘Occupied Territories’ in an attempt to deny the Jewish history of this area).
“Residents of Migron in Samaria (Shomron) have appealed to the HighCourt to cancel an expulsion order following the secret purchase of most of the land by an American philanthropist.”
So.. my mum has a Chevron sticker on her car. Last week, she was stopped at a red light and an Israeli woman (who is also stopped at the light) literally got out of her car, walked to my mum’s car, tapped on her window and asked
“Did you used to live in Chevron?”
My mum was a little confused and answered “No…”
The woman persisted. “Does your son go to the Yeshiva in Chevron?”
My mum - still perturbed answered “No…”
The light then turned back to green and the woman returned to her car and continued driving.
On the first night of Shavuot I participated in a Tikkun Leil program organised by the local Zionist council. The program consisted of different discussion groups chaired by different Madrichim (counsellors/leaders) of the local Zionist youth groups. The entire spectrum of Judaism and Zionism was represented from Reform youth groups to Betar.
I attended a discussion on the existence of settlements in Judea and Samaria and whether or not they impede on Israel’s democratic nature. I believe that after this discussion, I discovered the reason why there is no peace in the Middle East.
Neither the Left Wingers nor the Right Wingers had any respect for each other. It was not an open environment where people legitimately wanted to hear the other side’s opinions and take them into consideration. Rather, both sides were hostile to each other and unwilling to consider the other’s opinions. Each person who spoke was mocked by the opposing side and nothing productive came of the session.
Such discussions on a simple level, like the one I attended and on a larger, more serious, political level will be unproductive and fruitless unless both sides respect each other, respect each other’s opinions and create an environment where genuine debate is appreciated.
So, what’s the moral of the story?
You know your opinion.
I know mine.
We both need open minds and a respect for one another to actually engage in academic discussion. If this ever happens in the Tumblr community…I’ll be really pleased.
Maybe, if we can do it, we can actually make an impact!
Unfortunately today in Israel, the government voted against a bill that would officially legalize the Ulpana neighborhood as well as other neighborhoods in Judea and Samaria. The fact that our own government, a Likud, supposedly right wing government is not supporting the Jewish presence in Yesha…
-Jewish communities are surrounded by fences
-Jews are not allowed to hike in the Wadi under their community
-Jews can’t visit the surrounding villages
-Jews can’t leave the community at certain hours
BECAUSE OF THE THREAT OF DEATH
“Last week, I returned from month-long reserve service session in Judea and Samaria; it was my first stint in the territories since my mandatory IDF service.
Undoubtedly, things look different when you are a few years older. Different situations become clearer, and new conclusions emerge. Forget about everything you were told: Roadblocks, control, humiliation, apartheid? Not around here. I encountered a different reality, and below are my impressions.
Every person is allowed to be shocked by something else, in line with one’s doctrine, morality, values and worldview. Some see a moral crime in a military patrol that holds up a Palestinian for a security check and are deeply shaken by it. I chose to be shocked by other things.
I was shocked to realize that some Israelis maintain a daily routine under a constant threat to their lives, and that a Jewish community must be surrounded by a fence so its residents won’t be butchered. I suddenly understood how truly shocking it is that I’m lying in ambush in mud near a Jewish community on the eve of a holiday, just to prevent the murder of Jews by the local population; of course, a holiday is a wonderful date for terror groups to hurt the Jews a little more.
I was shocked that Jews are not allowed to hike in the wadi under their community, that they must not enter surrounding villages because they won’t come out alive, that their movement is limited, that at certain hours one must not leave the community, and that they face the constant threat of stoning, firing and lynching.
For years we are hearing the lie that our presence there constitutes an obstacle to peace, while we come up with all sorts of odd excuses for murderous terror. They are not telling us about the massacre in Hebron’s Jewish community in 1929, some 38 years before Judea and Samaria was conquered. We are not told that between 1949 and 1956, more than 300 Jewish civilians were murdered in “Palestinian” terror attacks.
Nobody tells us that the Palestine Liberation Organization was formed in 1964, three years before Judea and Samaria was conquered under the command of IDF Chief of Staff Yitzhak Rabin. Any territory handed over to the Palestinians to this day has been used to produce terror infrastructure, and the latest example – the Gush Katif evacuation – demonstrates it in the clearest and more blatant manner.
The Palestinians do not draw their hatred for Israel from the soldier at the checkpoint. That’s my own opinion, of course. They take in the hatred from Palestinian Authority and Hamas TV, where Jews are compared to monkeys and pigs worthy of death. They get the hatred from incitement at mosques, schools, and the photos of martyrs adorning every wall and square in Judea and Samaria cities.
They draw the motivation to hate from Palestinian cultural icons, Marwan Barghouti and mass murderer Yasser Arafat. They are inspired by squares and soccer stadiums named after terrorists; years of incitement and dehumanization of Israel are having their effect.
To my regret, I realized that the equation is clear and simple: Without our presence there, we would witness the mass slaughter of Jews at the hands of Arabs, making the 1929 riots seem like child’s play.
There is no doubt that IDF soldiers face complex situations while serving in the territories. My comrades and I, who were called up to serve there, did not arrive in order to see blood spilled, heaven forbid, humiliate or trample the honor of Palestinians. The opposite is true.
We were all educated in line with Zionist values, tolerance and the desire for peace, regardless of leftist or rightist views. I know that the real Left is not about radical activists or the violent anarchists who hurl stones at IDF troops on Fridays. For me, the real Left is about Rabin, may he rest in peace, Zionism, building, and friendship. Even if we don’t always agree, we still keep fighting shoulder to shoulder.
Even if we cast the political debate aside for a moment, I feel proud to serve in Judea and Samaria. I’m proud that thanks to me and my fellow reservists, residents celebrated Passover safely without being murdered. I’m proud that the roadblock I served at prevented a knifeman or an explosive device from entering the Green Line. I’m also proud that my presence averted the hurling of rocks at Jewish cars. I’m proud of performing all these missions and preventing murder and harm to human life.”
It Takes Two - Peace In The Middle East
Fogel Family Memorial 2012
I made this video in order to commemorate the first Yahrtzeit of the Fogel Family HY’D.
A year ago, 6th Adar (11 March 2011), five members of the same family were murdered in their beds. The victims were the father Ehud (Udi) Fogel, the mother Ruth Fogel, and three of their six children—Yoav, 11, Elad, 4, and Hadas, the youngest, a three-month-old infant.